Two Eastern Washington State farms that specialize in growing soft white wheat have filed a class action lawsuit in Spokane federal court against Monsanto. The first class action, was filed against Monsanto over its release of unauthorized genetically engineered wheat, and represents all domestic soft white wheat farmers. More than 46% of U.S. soft white wheat comes from Washington state.
Monsanto field tested genetically-engineered wheat resistant to the herbicide Roundup in 16 states from 1998 and 2005, although the wheat had never been approved for planting in the United States. The same strain that was never approved was found growing on an eastern Oregon farm last month, although Monsanto maintains that it halted its trials nine years ago.
The lawsuit contends that the discovery of Monsanto’s unapproved wheat has detrimentally affected the ability of soft white wheat farmers to sell their wheat into export channels as many countries, such as Japan and South Korea, are cancelling orders and refusing to accept imports of domestic soft white wheat. These import restrictions could prove financially devastating to soft white wheat farmers in the Pacific Northwest. Nearly 90 percent of the Pacific Northwest’s soft white wheat crop is exported to Asian nations, where it is used to make noodles and crackers.
The Complaint alleges that Monsanto and its field trial operators knew that conventional wheat could become contaminated with Monsanto’s genetically-engineered wheat through commingling and other means during the harvest, storage, transport, and disposal process, yet failed to take the necessary steps to prevent this from occurring. The lawsuit further contends that Monsanto knew that the existence of genetically-engineered wheat commingled within the general wheat supply would cause significant disruptions in the wheat export market and financially damage wheat farmers.
Mark Deife, a partner with Tousley Brain Stephens, noted, “Monsanto’s genetically engineered seed discovered in Oregon may have been sold through normal commercial channels. My family has been growing soft white wheat in Eastern Washington for over a century and if Monsanto’s unauthorized wheat has entered the stream of commerce, it could be devastating for all soft white wheat exports.”
James Pizzirusso, a partner with Hausfeld LLP, stated, “Monsanto is playing with the economic livelihood of all wheat farmers. Their assurances of the contamination in Oregon as being an ‘isolated occurrence’ ring hollow.” The Monsanto complaint can be accessed here: http://www.hausfeldllp.com/content_documents/16/Complaint.pdf